Anonymous1 wrote: ↑Mon Mar 31, 2025 6:56 pm
jimbob17 wrote: ↑Mon Mar 31, 2025 6:42 pm
Anonymous1 wrote: ↑Fri Mar 28, 2025 12:48 am
7 from the 2021 U20’s have consistently started this year.
Pearson, Egan x2, Furlong, Flynn, O’Neill and Bryant
Yea but Egan, Furlong and O'Neil were brought into that u20 set up very late before 1st rnd after their u18 minor team lost Leinster Final. They would not have been let go in if they'd beaten Meath in minor and in all likelihood, wouldn't have won u20s without them 3 lads.
It's often said about these 7 but they are pulled from 3 yrs of age gap - ie minor groups of 2018, 2019 and 2020.
You could argue the minors of 2014, 2015 and 2016 minor teams have given just as much to current senior team in Paddy Dunican, Ruairi McNamee, David Dempsey, Jack McEvoy, Kyle Higgins, Jordan Hayes, Dylan Hyland, Shane Tierney, Aaron Leavy and possibly SOT Greene and Jack O'Brien there on panel also and might be missing one or more - this is not including Cian Farrell or Cian Johnson, Colm Doyle, Cathal Mangan, Chillie Donnelly and few more who all came off those years and went on to play senior afterwards. One of the best underage players then was Micheal Mooney from Durrow who I wouldve thought wouldve gone on to play senior but never made it through.
Yeah but not all of those you’ve listed have been consistent starters.
If we’re including subs then there are 5 more of the 2021 U20’s who were on yesterday’s bench and I’m sure Kieran Dolan would’ve been there too only for that horrific injury a couple of years back.
The reality is Offaly have managed to get an unusually high % of those players through to the senior ranks.
I read in the programme that of the 40+ Kildare players that played in their 2018 and 2023 All Ireland wins - only 7 are on the senior panel.
Fair enough but off that list I gave, 8 of them have been consistent starters either this year or last year. McNamee and Dempsey were consistent starters last number of years. This is not a competition between these groups but credit where it is due i'd feel. Without Hayes, Hyland and Dunican leading as they did in earlier games, we wouldnt have got promotion in my opinion. Other lads not named above that wouldve been part of those 2014-16 groups would include likes of Jamie Evans, Jason Dempsey, Clint Horan, PJ Daly and Jack Walsh who all also played senior in NFL in addition to those 17 players I listed above. That is a fair chunk of a return with 21 in total and I may be missing some too....
I still think Jamie Evans should be on the current senior squad and I think he has lot more to offer than a couple of the subs. Liam Kearns thought enough of him to start him in championship in his first year back after he was 19 or 20 and went travelling and Kearns knew a thing or two about football to be fair. They were a strong group that did well at underage and minor and many of whom got to an U21 Leinster final only to lose out to a stacked Dublin team that contributed to one of the best senior teams of all time and at U21 included Brian Howard, Eoin Murchan, Con O Callaghan, Sean Bugler, Evan Comerford, Cian Murphy and Collie Basquel among others I am sure - all of whom have won All Irelands at senior level on the field of play. Aaron Byrne among others were also there and went on to win All Irelands as subs on those All Ireland senior winning teams.
They'd all be 25-28 now and some would've got more chances at senior but for that exceptional younger crop coming through. There is a train of thought and opinion out there that it is all of those u20 lads coming through that is the reason for the recent success. Yes, they played huge part and are currently doing the business which is great but I think some of the older lads deserve a bit of credit too to be fair.
As for this years team, that is a fair amount of turnover from last week. Any idea on what the team is?