jimbob17 wrote: ↑Sat Dec 07, 2024 3:23 amIve never heard so much rot said One Time. It really sounds like you have a major agenda and that you want to totally ignore a hammering at home to London and ignore TC 2024 results. I just wonder why you want DK treated different to any other manager over last 20 years. Last year was simply horrific and if anyone else got those results, they would have been removed. Full Stop! They did only very OK in league but there was too much negativity and stories emanating from squad. I was at the Westmeath game last year in Rnd 1. It was embarassing we were so far off them. That squad nearly got promoted in 23 under Kearns. Panda was central to that and he was left out despite being one of our best forwards. Anton was central to that, as was Cunningham. They also had the U20s coming through in 2024 - most of them 22-23 and with 2 years senior experience behind them from 22 and 23 - and you are still only 'bedding them in'!One Time wrote: ↑Fri Dec 06, 2024 4:20 pmLeave aside the tailteann cup and we were competitive in every game of the league and should have won more of them and the teams in division 3 some went on to have good championships, we easily disposed of Laois in championship who weren't beaten much in the TC final, forget about the Tailteann cup from offaly perspective, no one bothered..a bit of luck and our league campaign would have been very different after bedding in a few new players who will have hugely benefitted from that, more of the same this year and we'll get promoted.. antons game is based on pace and taking on his man, not something that's easy do as you hit 33.. can I name 12 better forwards? That's missing the point, we need players to play the game management want to play, players that will improve individually and improve the team and build for the future. I still say last year with a bit of luck would have been very differentAnonymous1 wrote: ↑Fri Dec 06, 2024 10:30 am
Ah come off it, we went the route of clearing house and playing the youth last year and we put in the worst performance of an Offaly Senior football team in the history of the county.
The definition of insanity…
The major elephant in the room was that there was way too much friction and negativity in and around the squad last year. It isnt a secret that a good few players fell out with DK and a few left the squad through the year and a very senior player left early in the year calling it a toxic environment. That is not good and says a lot and that showed in the Tailteann Cup results. Now if the Tailteann Cup didnt involve the most embarassing result in the last 50 years or more - a 14 pt championship defeat to London at home, then I'd say something but thats what we are talking about here. You cant just say that the TC shouldnt be counted to suit your agenda. That matters a LOT! That is what they were training for all year - the one championship we had a chance in and our main competition to train for. You are the one missing the point!!! Even players and management said as much in the week leading into the London game in local media!
If anyone else got them results and there was that level of negativity within a camp, then they'd be removed. Ignoring that and talking about bedding in players is totally missing the point. DK had the U20s from 2018 - 2022 approx. He knew what was there. Senior is not a development team for bedding in. We are building every year since about 2007 from what I can see. That is just a bulshit excuse to try explain away below par performances. Senior is about getting your absolute best team on the pitch and staying competitive in that given year and all the signs last year showed our curve going majorly in the wrong direction. You cant just ignore the facts.
I'd only love if it all went to plan and it was a rosy in the garden but it wasn't. DK did a lot at under 20 level but did he lose the dressing room this year? Anton is definitely in the top 8 forwards in the county, no doubt about it. He'd be on my best team most days irrespective of age and id be fairly sure that he'd be among the top 10 athletes in the squad so age is not an issue and should not be an excuse. Maybe there is a personality clash and that appears to be the case - fairly sure there was an issue between them last year and maybe Kelly feels threatened by anyone who may have a bit of knowledge or more inter county senior experience than he does within the camp who is not afraid to express their thoughts. That said, it is within managements rights to select THEIR panel and if that is the way it falls, then so be it, but i'd sense it is a poor call by management and a mistake. But lets wait and see. February isnt too far away.
With the 3x3 rule in, it couldve really suited Sullivan and I think if DK was more clever, he'd have found a way, irrespective of any personality clash that may or may not have arisen. We dont have the talent to just ignore a lad with Antons ability and fitness. You wouldnt meet a more dedicated lad in fairness to him and I think we will definitely see him in a county jersey again if he wants to keep in shape for a year or so. That said, not sure it is helpful for Anton to air dirty linen in public and even if it is Verney going to him as appears to be the case, then I think it doesnt reflect so well.
I wouldnt be fully sure how long this new set-up will last and if I was a betting man, id imagine either Harte or Kelly will move on after a year or so after more mediocre results and or a better offer elsewhere for Harte, with the managers job then becoming vacant. If that were to happen, I couldnt see DK going back in on his own or be given that opportunity and it'd probably take a brand new management team then to take over - and Anton, could very easily find himself back in the frame if that were to materialise.
So essentially what you want is to continue to play with the same lads (a lot of who are in their 30s now) that have achieved little or nothing over the last 10 years with offaly and play them till they retire or whatever and don't give new young lads a chance to play and develop into senior players (bearing in mind these are lads that have actually won something)and when the older lads retire we have a new team through with no experience and worse still they get pissed off looking at these older lads dictating the dressing room and winning nothin and keeping them out of the team and we lose them? Is that what you want? I wouldn't have DK or Mickey harte by the way but a lot of new players got a lit of league time and performed probably as well as could have been expected, if you actually analyse the results and how the other teams went in championship after, it certainly gave our league form a boost and again yes I am happy to write off the TC because we simply didn't bother.. you want to analyse TC like it's a reflection of the team and it certainly is not and you know that aswell. I'm gonna find it hard to actually support the team this year because mickey harte is manager and I loathe him with a passion but I believe the new players that I have experience behind them from last year's league campaign that will show through this year, have to move on.. and we have not been building we've had the same shite and same lads ruling the dressing room and dictating and making the dressing room negative, it's time to get rid of all that shite and move on with new players who have already won with and who want to play for the team and management.