Good synopsis BnM man, as always, but just to step away from the detail a bit, and give my overall impressions. Not to put a fine a point on it, I thought were were abysmal.
We didn't seem to have any plan or method of play at all in the attacking end of the field, never mind a plan B. Lads were playing off the cuff and as individuals. Not, I sensed, out of selfishness, but out of a lack of understanding of what they were supposed to be doing. Every time we got the ball, there was no sense of anticipation about what was going to happen. And I don't think this was a deliberate ploy to keep Tipp guessing, because Offaly looked as if they were guessing just as much.
We are, and remain, miles off the required standard. As far off it as I have seen, because while we have struggled before, the rest of the field were stagnant enough and a 'good year' could make you competitive instantly. This is different. In terms of preparation we are a mile away, and we need to sort that out now. No more excuses, no more stupid managerial culls, this is basic, hard hard work on the players behalf. They need to be given the guidance and oversight, and they do not need to live like monks, but they need to change preparation methods. Not from February for 'The Championship' either, but from September/October. We are, I would say, about 6-8 years behind, and the only way we will catch up is by outworking other teams. Not by just doing as much as them.
We also need a system of play that can be adapted depending on circumstance. Whether that be a Donegal style defensive/counter attacking system, a Crossmaglen direct style, a Kerry combination, a Cork system of power runners, whatever it is, it needs to be set out at the start of the year and worked on for at least 2 years. If they start on this from October, they will see results in the Spring and Summer, but it can be tweaked and modified and expanded as the years go by. At the moment, we are neither fish, nor fowl. And I think if you asked an Offaly player what sort of game they play, he'd struggle to tell you.
Without preparation, physical and tactical, we will continue to drift on and by standing still, we are going irrevocably backwards. Time to change the momentum. It is possible, and you do not need to unearth 24 All stars to do it. However, you do need a clear idea, commitment to the plan, and hard, hard work. You also need patience, from players and fans. Everyone has to buy in. But it is possible, let's stop talking, and just do it.
With a clear head, and no bias. Do we think we could, on any given day, approach any team with confidence at the moment? Lets count them.
First our Leinster foes.
Louth - Maybe, because they are in a worse state than we are at the moment behind the scenes.
Meath - Nope.
Dublin - Nope
Wicklow - I wouldn't feel confident, but maybe.
Wexford - Nope
Carlow - I wouldn't feel confident, but maybe.
Kilkenny - Yes
Laois - Nope
Kildare - Nope
Westmeath - Nope
Longford - Nope
So out of the 11 counties in Leinster, I'd think we have a reasonable chance against 3, and confident against only 1, Kilkenny.
Now Connacht, the 'weakest' province.
Galway - Nope
Mayo - Nope
Roscommon - Nope
Sligo - Nope
Leitrim - Maybe, but wouldn't be over confident
London - Maybe, but wouldn't be over confident
New York - Yes
So over in the west, I think we'd be well beaten by 4, in with a chance in 2 and confident in one.
Munster
Cork - Nope
Kerry - Nope
Tipperary - Nope
Limerick - Nope
Clare - Very maybe, but I doubt it.
Waterford - Maybe, but wouldn't be over confident.
Down south I'd say reasonable v the Deise, and an outside chance v Clare.
Ulster
Donegal - Nope
Cavan - Maybe, but not confident
Monaghan - Nope
Fermanagh - Maybe, but not confident
Antrim - Maybe, but not confident
Tyrone - Nope
Derry - Nope
Armagh - Nope
Down - Nope
I'd give us a fighting chance against 3 teams, but wouldn't expect a win in any.
So by my highly unscientific gut feel if we were in a draw against all the other 33 counties, including Kilkenny, London and New York, I'd only be confident we could beat 2 of them. Kilkenny and New York. I'd give us a fighting chance, without any great expectations in another 10, and no chance except a miracle or an 'on the day' thing versus another 21. Maybe that says more about my mental state with regard to Offaly football at the moment, but even 5 years ago I'd have had much higher numbers in the confident and fighting chance category, including teams that have left us behind like Laois, Longford, Wexford, Meath, Kildare, Roscommon, Sligo, Tipperary, Limerick, etc etc etc. I'm in bad form today
