Re: The Camogie thread
Posted: Thu Aug 19, 2010 9:12 pm
A journey into the unknown for the Offaly girls on Saturday. Not so much about the opposition but about themselves.
It’s been quite a while since their last competitive game – the last week of June in fact, before the weather broke. When compared to the Senior championship (which gave 6 group matches over 7 weeks) the Intermediate championship gave teams scant chance to gain momentum.
Then there’s a concern as to just how well Offaly are playing. Looking at their results the group they were in was lobsided with Wexford and Offaly considerably stronger than Kilkenny and Galway. Offaly freshened up the team after the first-round defeat to Wexford with a few changes which paid dividends as a hungry Offaly saw off Galway a week later.
While training and challenge matches are good practice, they can be misleading when assessing the form of fringe players – instance Waterford’s gamble on Brian O’Halloran leading to a dud betting slip.
Derry could be considered to be two years ahead of Offaly in their development. They were the team who beat Clare with a late goal in the 2007 Junior final (Clare’s motivation for winning the Junior title beating Offaly a year later). They were the form team in June and topped a competitive group despite playing all their matches at neutral venues.
The carrot of playing the Intermediate final in Croke Park will add extra spice though, and playing at an Inter-county ground like Clones is infinitely better than playing on a cabbage-patch in rural Cavan, where the semi-final was originally fixed.
Looking forward, going to Senior level is a target of this Offaly team. Thing is, are they really ready to move up to the bear-pit that is Senior camogie? Results against other Senior teams is not encouraging and perhaps the match Offaly should have targeted this year was the League final which offered a chance to play the top teams in wintertime – a stepping stone to playing them in summer.
Still, with Wexford having Offaly’s number and Limerick having played at Senior level for some years the winner of the other semi-final will likely be favourites to win it out. Time will tell. Hopefully Offaly can at least get to the final and give themselves a fighting chance of a title win.
Herewith the four semi-finalists’ form in the group stages: -
Offaly: lost to Wexford 1-8 to 1-10, beat Galway 2-20 to 2-8 and beat Kilkenny 2-17 to 1-5.
Derry: beat Tipperary 4-17 to 4-7, beat Limerick 2-8 to 0-11 and beat Cork 1-17 to 1-9.
Wexford: beat Offaly 1-10 to 1-8, beat Kilkenny 4-20 to 0-6 and beat Galway 6-5 to 1-6.
Limerick: drew with Cork 2-7 each, lost to Derry 0-11 to 2-8 and beat Tipperary 2-12 to 0-5.
It’s been quite a while since their last competitive game – the last week of June in fact, before the weather broke. When compared to the Senior championship (which gave 6 group matches over 7 weeks) the Intermediate championship gave teams scant chance to gain momentum.
Then there’s a concern as to just how well Offaly are playing. Looking at their results the group they were in was lobsided with Wexford and Offaly considerably stronger than Kilkenny and Galway. Offaly freshened up the team after the first-round defeat to Wexford with a few changes which paid dividends as a hungry Offaly saw off Galway a week later.
While training and challenge matches are good practice, they can be misleading when assessing the form of fringe players – instance Waterford’s gamble on Brian O’Halloran leading to a dud betting slip.
Derry could be considered to be two years ahead of Offaly in their development. They were the team who beat Clare with a late goal in the 2007 Junior final (Clare’s motivation for winning the Junior title beating Offaly a year later). They were the form team in June and topped a competitive group despite playing all their matches at neutral venues.
The carrot of playing the Intermediate final in Croke Park will add extra spice though, and playing at an Inter-county ground like Clones is infinitely better than playing on a cabbage-patch in rural Cavan, where the semi-final was originally fixed.
Looking forward, going to Senior level is a target of this Offaly team. Thing is, are they really ready to move up to the bear-pit that is Senior camogie? Results against other Senior teams is not encouraging and perhaps the match Offaly should have targeted this year was the League final which offered a chance to play the top teams in wintertime – a stepping stone to playing them in summer.
Still, with Wexford having Offaly’s number and Limerick having played at Senior level for some years the winner of the other semi-final will likely be favourites to win it out. Time will tell. Hopefully Offaly can at least get to the final and give themselves a fighting chance of a title win.
Herewith the four semi-finalists’ form in the group stages: -
Offaly: lost to Wexford 1-8 to 1-10, beat Galway 2-20 to 2-8 and beat Kilkenny 2-17 to 1-5.
Derry: beat Tipperary 4-17 to 4-7, beat Limerick 2-8 to 0-11 and beat Cork 1-17 to 1-9.
Wexford: beat Offaly 1-10 to 1-8, beat Kilkenny 4-20 to 0-6 and beat Galway 6-5 to 1-6.
Limerick: drew with Cork 2-7 each, lost to Derry 0-11 to 2-8 and beat Tipperary 2-12 to 0-5.